Lacan’s Psychoanalysis and Plato’s Symposium:
نویسنده
چکیده
There are very real limitations to any discussion of Jacques Lacan’s complex and voluminous commentary on Plato’s Symposium, not least in a paper of this length. The sheer number of connections that Lacan makes cannot be fully dealt with, nor can any particular point of interest be exhaustively discovered without drawing other issues into the fold. Nevertheless, what I have presented in this discussion is a suggestive interpretation of Lacan’s interest in the relationship between Socrates and Alcibiades, insofar as this relationship makes a certain common understanding of love in Plato and psychoanalysis emerge. What I suggest is that Lacan’s interpretation makes it possible to understand how, in the ancient text, desire is already understood as an unconscious motivation, not only in terms of its inexorable power to determine a person’s aims, but also in its ability to subsist between and beyond the rules of conscious discourse. Lacan highlights the particular point at which, within his speech on love, Socrates must hand over his explanation to the priestess Diotima, who as a functionary between the gods and human beings is in a unique position to give a description of desire’s metaxological status in the form of a myth. It remains a point of interest why Plato, who specifically disdains the status of myth as a form of true discourse, nonetheless includes them at certain points. In relation to the Symposium, it is precisely because desire subsists beyond or between the “activities of love” in the Socratic sense that an explanation must be sought beyond the efficacy of what Lacan understands as Socrates’s otherwise unanswerable interrogations of the signifying order. Lacan begins his psychoanalytic interpretation of Plato’s Symposium in the second session of the seminar on transference, where he initiates his audience with a discussion of the dialogue’s somewhat scandalous and unexpected character; it is perhaps even a special kind of literature that “could be considered a statutory offence by a police inquiry.” The dialogue itself has a transgressive 1
منابع مشابه
The Dialectic of Truth and Appearance in Lacan’s Reading of Gerhard Richter’s Overpainted-from-photographs
One of the most important contemporary theoretical approaches that can be used to analyze works of art is the theories of Jacques Lacan (1901-1980), a French post-structuralist psychoanalyst. By combining psychoanalysis, philosophy, linguistics, and anthropology, he analyzes the world of the human subject’s mind in a series of intertwined and extensive cultural and social relationships.This art...
متن کاملConcepts of Temporality in the Theory of Transference
This paper examines the temporal concepts that underlie the theory of transference in psychoanalysis. The paper reviews Freud’s rejection of linear temporality as characteristic of unconscious thought in favour of regression, repetition, and deferred action. It then develops concepts drawn from Jacques Lacan’s theory of the formation of the ego. Here, the biologically determined helplessness de...
متن کاملA Comprehensive Introduction to Lacan's Theories of Psychosis
on Lacan’s lesser-known psychiatric influences such as de Clérambault, the description of the centrality of language phenomena in psychosis, and, the clarity of the exposition, entails that these ideas are well worth revisiting. A considerable strength of this section is how Vanheule is able to provide a clear exposition of central tenants of Lacanian theory in a manner that is both comprehensi...
متن کاملSe Faire Voir with Jung and the Ethics of Psychoanalysis
This article is an important addition to my previous work of integrating Jungian and Lacanian psychoanalysis (see Complexes Tickling the $ubject). A main focus of this article is to use Zizek’s interpretation of Lacan’s writing on desire and drive in relation to my Heideggerian interpretation of Jung. As a result, this article is an important contribution to the literature because it shows the ...
متن کاملEuropean journal of American studies, Vol 11, no 2 | 2016
This article uses Jacques Lacan’s reading of the Freudian fort-dagame to analyze that most American of cultural constructs, the cowboy, at the time of that figure’s fading from theAmerican landscape: the immediate postwar years. With John Grady Cole, the protagonist of All the Pretty Horses (1992), Cormac McCarthy provides a suitably situated subject for this criticalendeavor, one whose...
متن کامل